Manchester United’s statement confirming Michael Carrick’s departure called him a club legend and credited him with winning 12 of his 17 league games last season. No Premier League side took more points in that period.
Less than six months after giving him a contract until 2028, United decided a change was necessary. Both decisions made sense on the results. The way the club handled his exit is harder to defend.
Carrick returned on 13 January as interim head coach until the end of the season, following Ruben Amorim’s dismissal. He had already taken caretaker charge for three games after Ole Gunnar Solskjaer’s departure and spent two and a half years at Middlesbrough. This time, he beat Manchester City and Arsenal in his first two games, took United to third and secured Champions League football. By the time the club confirmed his permanent appointment on 22 May, he had earned it.
This season exposed how little of that progress United could sustain.
They took eight points from their first 10 league games and slipped to 18th. Carrick’s decision to leave captain Bruno Fernandes on the bench throughout a 3–0 home defeat by Bournemouth was particularly hard to justify as United struggled to create.
There was still fight in the side. They came from behind to beat Roma 3–2 and scored twice in stoppage time to draw 4–4 with Aston Villa. Yet conceding four at Old Trafford underlined how much work the team needed without the ball.
Carrick had enough games to show he could steady the team. He also deserved a more dignified exit than taking training on Wednesday while United reportedly reached a verbal agreement with his successor.
The people who gave him the job in May also shaped the squad he took into this season. They spent heavily on midfield and left a clear need at left-back unresolved. Carrick had to answer for his selections and results. United’s directors should answer for why a squad they expected to build on a third-place finish went into the season with such an obvious gap.
Mauricio Pochettino looks the likeliest replacement.
The United States head coach has reportedly agreed in principle to take over, while United’s statement says the club intends to appoint a permanent successor as quickly as possible. His record at Tottenham, where he reached the 2019 Champions League final, explains the appeal.
If appointed, his first job will be to make United harder to play against and get them out of the bottom three. What follows will depend on whether the club can give him a squad capable of playing the football it hires him to deliver.



